Mazak Vs Doosan – which one to choose?

There are several CNC brands available around the world that supply different styles of CNC machines with different advanced features but most of them lack one thing – trust of customers. But there are some brands too which have owned the trust of their customers by supplying top notch CNC machines to their customers over the years while innovating for the best features with more passing time. Two such brands are Doosan and Mazak, which need no introduction because everyone who is interested in machining knows them. But which one among them is better? Let’s find that out. 

Key differences between Mazak and Doosan:

Here are some of the major differences between the CNC machines of Mazak and Doosan:

1. Brand value and machine lineup: 
   • Mazak is a CNC machine brand, based out of Japan and known for its exceptionally strong built CNC machines. They have a long history of innovation, as they are also known as the pioneers of multi tasking CNC machines. They make different types of machines like CNC lathes, vertical/horizontal machining centers, multi-tasking, 5-axis, and hybrid additive/subtractive machines. 
   • The brand was started in South Korea, currently known as DN Solutions. Doosan offers robust and heavy duty frame CNC machines, which are also reliable and cost effective. The machines of Doosan are mostly used by industries that need high precision. They supply different styles of CNC machines like CNC lathes, vertical/horizontal machining centers, multi-axis, and multi-tasking machines. 
2. Build Quality and reliability: 
   • Mazak machines are reliable but seen as more delicate compared to the machines of Doosan, and also come at a more premium pricing range. The luxurious finishing of the Mazak CNC machines requires careful handling. Their machines are also priced for their longevity, while some long time users credit them to be running for several years. The only problem is the machines can be complex to handle and maintain but they also offer unmatched flexibility in machining. 
   • Doosan CNC machines are considered to be one of the best options when you are running them in harsh settings. They are also easier to maintain and come at a lower upfront cost when compared to the CNC machines of Mazak. Their machines are robust too, with a strong emphasis on foundational rigidity. 
3. Control system and programming:
   • Mazak has its own proprietary MAZATROL control system, renowned for their conversational programming features. They have a user-friendly, icon driven interface, which helps operators with less G-code knowledge to even do machining. They provide advanced simulation, real time monitoring features, and IoT connectivity features. The MAZATROL Fusion 640 even integrates a smart 64-bit RISC CPU and expert system for simpler programming. 
   • Doosan CNC machines are typically equipped with the FANUC control system, which is well celebrated for their openness and industry wide familiarity. This control system also has a lot of customization options.  Their control system is highly compatible with different types of CAM software. 
4. Innovation and automation: 
   • Mazak is one of the market leaders when it comes to smart manufacturing. They have the MAZATROL AI feature which helps in optimized programming while leveraging AI and virtual simulation for better accuracy and efficiency. They have worked on different innovative CNC technologies like PALLETECH automation, MPP system, and SmartBox feature for IIoT connectivity. 
   • Doosan CNC machines focus on practical automation solutions, as evident in their various features, including automatic tool changers and support for robotic loading and unloading. They also develop automation solutions that can be easily integrated with their existing production lines. 

Ideal use cases of Mazak and Doosan CNC machines:

Here’s a detailed explanation of when you should Doosan CNC machines, and when should you go with Mazak CNC machines:

When to choose Mazak CNC machines:

• If your operations need ultra high precision machines and multitasking. 
• Businesses investing in smart factory features and automation. 
• If you want machines that can be run by newbie operators. 

When to choose Doosan CNC machines:

• If you have a limited budget and have a shop with mixed runs. 
• If your shop has harsh environments and needs tough machining work. 
• If your work requires a long machining life. 

Summary of the advantages of Mazak and Doosan CNC machines: 

Here’s an exclusive chart of the key differences between Mazak and Doosan CNC machines: 

Conclusion:

Buying a CNC machine is a very important investment for your machining business, so it is necessary to make the right decision by taking all the pros and cons into consideration. In this case, both Mazak and Doosan bring some great advantages to the table so make your decision by analysing both sides. Also, if you are planning to buy machines of any one of these brands then you must check our collection of Used Mazak CNC Machines and Used Doosan CNC Machines and make the call after checking the features of the particular machine.